You need to consider the sequence within which DevTest operates when making its selections from a VSI.
Signature Analysis: DevTest tries to match the incoming request's Operation Name and Argument Names (not values) to find a list of candidate transactions to match on. Refer to this link for a better description: Stateless Transactions View - DevTest Solutions - 10.0 - CA Technologies Documentation
Match Tolerance: Defines how the VSE selects a given response from the list of transactions that pass the signature analysis. Refer to this link for a better description: Match Tolerance - DevTest Solutions - 10.0 - CA Technologies Documentation
- Operation The loosest match tolerance. The operation name of the incoming transaction must match the name of the recorded transaction.
- Signature The operation name must match and the names of the arguments must match exactly, with no additions or deletions. The order of arguments does not have to be the same.
- Exact In addition to the signature match, the values for each argument must match the values that were recorded, as defined by the argument match operators.
One way to think about the VSI (graphic below) is that the upper left hand portion of the Service Image Editor is more focused on signature analysis while the the lower left hand portion of the Service Image Editor is focused on Match Tolerance. The right hand side of the SI Editor is focused on specific values to match, and response data.
Therefore, I would generally consider a specific transaction (circled in Red) as an Exact Match and a META transaction as a Signature Match within their respective signature sets (i.e., the first signature which is highlighted in Blue in the top pane).
I typically use the Operation Match to represent a 'catch all' transaction that returns a response when neither the Exact nor Signature match selects a response. I consider an Operation Match as only having a META response. And, I place Exact and Signature matches before Operation matches. The idea here is that the VSI needs to start with a narrow selection and widen to a loose selection. It does not work the other way around.