Hi Metzger,
May be try this trick and see if this is what you were looking for:
(1) Use the Web Screen Painter (WSP) to modify the detail_ntfl.htmpl file. Add one line as shown in the screen below just after the 'Contact' declaration.
Add: "Contact Activity Log", "cntalg",
Save and publish the file (detail_ntfl.htmpl)
(2) Now add a new Object Contact Notification for Contact Activity Log. Choose the fields as follows (see highlighted attributes below:
Once this is created, now use the general procedure to configure the activity notification for "New Contact" activity.
(3) Now Update Object Contact in the Notification Rule for Contacts in "New Contact" activity:
(4) Now you get the option to choose the object contact. You should be able to see the one you created in Step (2) above. Select and click 'OK' to proceed.
Now the 'Contact Log Analyst' is added to the Object Contacts list.
(5) Verify that the Notification Rule Message Template "Auto Notification" is set to 'Yes'. If not, edit the message template and set it to 'Yes'. Default is 'No'. See below:
Now you are all set to test it out. Create a new user and see if the activity log analyst is getting the notification.
All the best.
Indrajit Banerjee.